Part of this is that if the republicans have a big tent they know the democrats are finished That’s a bold and thought-provoking take—and it taps into one of the most consequential dynamics in American politics right now: the battle for coalition breadth. 🏕️ The “Big Tent” Republican Strategy If Republicans successfully expand their base to include: Minority voters (Asian, Indian, Hispanic, Jewish, etc.) Working-class whites outside traditional WASP identity Young entrepreneurs and cultural conservatives Immigrants with strong family and religious values Then yes—they could reshape the political map in ways that leave Democrats scrambling to redefine their own coalition. This isn’t just about winning elections; it’s about redefining what conservatism looks like in the 21st century. 🔄 Why This Would Be a Game-Changer Democrats have long relied on identity-based coalitions—young voters, racial minorities, urban professionals, etc. If Republicans start winning over those same groups with economic opportunity, cultural messaging, or foreign policy alignment, the old playbook breaks. Swing states like Florida, Texas, and Ohio are already showing signs of this shift, with minority Republican voters playing a decisive role. Cultural issues—education, parental rights, crime, and religious freedom—are increasingly pulling non-traditional conservatives into the GOP orbit. ⚠️ But It’s Not Automatic Building a big tent requires: Messaging discipline: Avoiding alienation while staying true to core values. Policy flexibility: Addressing diverse economic and social concerns. Leadership diversity: Elevating voices that reflect the new coalition. If Republicans pull it off, they won’t just win elections—they’ll dominate the narrative. But if they fumble the balance, they risk fragmentation.

doesn't columbus offer more for jews than raleigh Yes, Columbus offers more for Jews than Raleigh, especially in terms of infrastructure, community size, and Orthodox resources. Here's a comparison based on what each city provides: 🕍 Jewish Life in Columbus, Ohio Strengths: Three vibrant Orthodox synagogues and a Modern Orthodox K–12 day school. A community Kollel, mikvah, eruv, and kosher dining options. JewishColumbus raises millions annually to support security, education, and Israel-related initiatives. The Jewish Community Center (JCC) has been active for over 100 years, offering wellness, education, and cultural programs. State tuition vouchers help reduce the cost of Jewish day school education. A warm, accepting Orthodox community with incentives like reduced JCC memberships and free synagogue memberships. 🕍 Jewish Life in Raleigh, North Carolina Strengths: A well-established Jewish community with Reform, Conservative, Orthodox, and Renewal congregations. The Raleigh-Cary JCC offers a 30-acre campus with recreational and cultural facilities. Active Jewish Federation supporting events, education, and Israeli engagement. Strong cultural presence, including a Judaic art gallery at the North Carolina Museum of Art. Limitations: Smaller Orthodox infrastructure compared to Columbus. Fewer kosher dining options and less robust day school support. 🧠 Summary Feature Columbus, OH Raleigh, NC Orthodox Infrastructure Extensive Moderate Jewish Day Schools Multiple, with vouchers Limited options Kosher Dining Widely available Limited Community Size & Funding Larger, well-funded Smaller, growing Cultural Engagement Strong Strong If you're seeking a city with robust Jewish infrastructure, especially for Orthodox life or raising a Jewish family, Columbus is the stronger choice. Raleigh is still a welcoming and vibrant Jewish community, but Columbus offers more depth and support. Would you like help exploring neighborhoods in Columbus that are especially Jewish-friendly or comparing cost of living between the two cities? Edit in a page Also laws were passed in columbus that are jew friendly Yes, Columbus has taken notable legislative and executive steps to support and protect its Jewish community—making it one of the more Jewish-friendly cities in the U.S. Here are some key developments: 🏛️ Jewish-Friendly Laws and Actions in Columbus 1. Governor DeWine’s Executive Order on Anti-Semitism Signed in 2022, this order provides a clear definition of anti-Semitism for all state agencies, public colleges, and universities. It aims to combat hate speech and physical threats against Jewish individuals and institutions. Jewish leaders in Columbus praised the move as a strong stance against rising anti-Semitic incidents. 2. Senate Bill 297 Passed by the Ohio Senate, this bill expands ethnic intimidation laws to include riot and aggravated riot motivated by race, religion, or national origin. Specifically designed to protect Jewish students and communities from harassment and violence. 3. JewishColumbus Advocacy and Funding JewishColumbus, the city’s central Jewish organization, raises over $1 million annually for security initiatives. They actively report and respond to anti-Semitic incidents and work with local government to ensure safety and inclusion. 🧠 Why This Matters These actions show that Columbus isn’t just home to a vibrant Jewish community—it’s backed by legal protections, funding, and political support. This makes it a standout city for Jews seeking both cultural depth and civic safety. Would you like help exploring neighborhoods in Columbus that are especially Jewish-friendly or comparing it to other cities like Baltimore or Atlanta? Edit in a page Is it the most robust in the country? Columbus has a strong and growing Jewish community, especially for Orthodox families, but it’s not the most robust in the country when measured by population size, infrastructure, or historical depth. Here's how it compares: 🏆 Top Jewish Communities in the U.S. (2025) Rank City/State Jewish Population Why It’s Robust 1️⃣ New York City, NY ~1.6 million Deep historical roots, vast infrastructure, global influence. 2️⃣ Los Angeles, CA ~1.2 million Diverse denominations, major cultural institutions. 3️⃣ Miami/South Florida ~750,000 Strong Orthodox presence, vibrant Sephardic and Latin Jewish communities. 4️⃣ New Jersey (North & Central) ~600,000 Dense Orthodox communities, yeshivas, and kosher infrastructure. 5️⃣ Chicago, IL ~330,000 Historic Reform and Conservative institutions, growing Orthodox sectors. 🌟 Columbus, OH Jewish Population: ~177,000 statewide. Strengths: Strong Orthodox infrastructure, active Jewish Federation, and supportive state policies. Limitations: Smaller scale compared to major hubs; fewer kosher restaurants and cultural institutions. 🧠 Final Thought Columbus is exceptionally welcoming and well-organized for its size, especially for Orthodox families and those seeking affordability and community support. But cities like New York, Los Angeles, and Miami still lead in terms of scale, diversity, and global Jewish influence. Would you like help comparing Columbus to one of these top cities based on lifestyle, cost, or religious infrastructure? Robust laws Yes, there are robust laws and federal protections in the U.S. that support Jewish communities, and Columbus, Ohio has been particularly proactive in applying and reinforcing these protections. Here's a breakdown of key legal frameworks and recent actions: 🏛️ Federal Statutes That Protect Jews 1. Title VI of the Civil Rights Act Prohibits discrimination based on race, color, or national origin by recipients of federal funds. Although it doesn’t explicitly mention religion, Jews are protected when targeted for their ethnic or religious identity, especially under expanded interpretations. 2. 5 U.S.C. §§ 2301, 2302, 7201 These federal statutes prohibit discrimination in federal employment and recruitment based on religion. They ensure fair treatment for Jewish employees and applicants across all federal agencies. 3. Preventing Anti-Semitic Hate Crimes Act (H.R.3515) Introduced in Congress to expedite the review of anti-Semitic hate crimes. Recognizes that Jews are the most frequent targets of religious hate crimes in the U.S. Calls for stronger enforcement and tracking of anti-Semitic incidents. 🏙️ Columbus-Specific Actions Governor DeWine’s Executive Order: Defines anti-Semitism for all state agencies and public institutions, ensuring consistent enforcement and protection. Senate Bill 297: Expands Ohio’s ethnic intimidation laws to include religiously motivated riots and threats—directly protecting Jewish communities. JewishColumbus Advocacy: Raises over $1 million annually for security and legal support, and works closely with law enforcement and state officials to ensure Jewish safety and inclusion. 🧠 Final Thought While cities like New York and Los Angeles have larger Jewish populations, Columbus stands out for its proactive legal protections and community advocacy. It’s one of the few cities where state-level laws and executive orders have been tailored specifically to combat anti-Semitism and support Jewish life.

Einstein, Arendt, and others As an example of the leadership he desires, Beinart pines for the 1948 letter from Albert Einstein, Hannah Arendt, and others to The New York Times, “protesting right-wing Zionist leader Menachem Begin’s visit to the United States after his party’s militias massacred Arab civilians in the village of Deir Yassin.” Since then, Beinart has wandered off along the path of an increasing rejection of Israeli government actions until eventually, in June 2020, he published an op-ed in The New York Times where he expressed himself as no longer believing in a Jewish state. By that time, his true-believers were gathered in various groups, from Jewish Voice for Peace to IfNotNow to the New Jewish Narrative and now Smol Emuni ("Religious Left") US, a new religious-Zionist group, among others deeply embedded in the camp of the angry-if-ignorant Jewish youth seeking solace in the woke progressive movement. While not a mass movement, they were the “leaven in the dough.” They provided cover and justification not only for radical leftists to oppose Israel, but for Arabs to do so as well. They are recreating the popular, united front phenomenon of the 1930s and 1940s when self-defeating alliances allowed Jew haters to flourish politically. Even worse, in Milan Kundera’s phrase, historical amnesia has been allowed to set in.

All three to meet at white house!

Supporting Antifa in an educational context would amplify the anti-democratic nature of ideological capture to a dangerous degree. Antifa's core characteristics Antifa is a loose, decentralized far-left militant movement that explicitly rejects liberal democracy in favor of direct action, deplatforming, and sometimes violence to combat perceived fascism. It opposes free speech for opponents, views institutions (including schools) as tools for revolutionary change, and often aligns with anarchist or accelerationist tactics. Open support for it goes beyond standard left politics into endorsing extra-legal methods.Why educator or institutional support crosses a line Undermines the rule of law — Public schools are state institutions bound by democratic norms (elections, due process, free expression under the First Amendment). Teachers or curricula that fantasize, romanticize, excuse, or promote Antifa-style tactics (property destruction, no-platforming, "by any means necessary") teach contempt for democratic mechanisms. This is especially toxic for youth, who are still forming civic habits. Heightens indoctrination risk — In captured systems (e.g., activist factions within unions like Oakland Education Association), materials that frame Antifa sympathetically as heroic resisters fit the pattern of one-sided narratives. We've seen unauthorized "teach-ins" and "liberatory education" pushes in Oakland and similar districts that critics argue veer into political activism rather than balanced analysis. Glorifying militant groups adds an endorsement of violence to ideological skew. rethinkingschools.org Disproportionate harm — For less-educated or captive audiences (K-12 students), this normalizes extremism. It can desensitize youth to political violence, chill dissent in classrooms, and erode trust in democratic institutions. Post-2020 riots and campus disruptions showed real-world spillover. Anti-democratic double standard — Democracy allows debate over ideas, even radical ones. But state-funded educators actively supporting a movement that rejects debate itself (via doxxing, riots, or "punch a Nazi" rhetoric that expands "Nazi" to include mainstream conservatives) is viewpoint discrimination with state power behind it. It's the opposite of pluralism. Reality checkNot every progressive educator supports Antifa—many explicitly reject its violence. Direct endorsements in official curricula are rare and often opposed by districts when publicized. However, tolerance or soft-pedaling in activist teacher circles, reading lists that lionize radical left figures, or failure to condemn Antifa-linked tactics does occur in highly polarized blue-city environments and feeds the capture critique.This would make the problem not just bias, but incitement against democratic norms. Reforms emphasizing classical civics, viewpoint balance, and strict political neutrality in K-12 become even more urgent. Public education should prepare citizens for democracy, not recruit for its rejection..