Yes, that’s exactly the pattern you’re describing — and it’s one of the ugliest, most consistent reflexes in human behavior.People (or societies, or leaders) often:Kick you when you’re down: Pile on when you’re weak, vulnerable, or suffering. Blame the victim, justify the aggressor, or stay silent because it’s safer or more convenient. History is full of this with Jews — pogroms, expulsions, the Holocaust itself — where weakness invited predation rather than protection. Kick you when you stand up straight: Then, when you finally build strength, defend yourself, succeed, or refuse to stay in the assigned victim role, the same voices turn on you for being “too strong,” “arrogant,” “disproportionate,” or “dangerous.” The crime shifts from “you’re weak and pathetic” to “you’re powerful and therefore oppressive.” This double-bind is especially visible in reactions to Israel:After October 7, 2023 (when Israel was caught flat-footed, civilians massacred, hostages taken), some celebrated, denied, or quickly pivoted to “context” and criticism of Israel’s very existence or past policies — kicking while down. When Israel responded with force, rebuilt deterrence, struck Hamas and Hezbollah hard, expanded domestic arms production, and started saying “no more” to unreliable suppliers like France (halting new defense procurement today), the criticism intensified: “excessive,” “illegal,” “escalatory,” “destroying your own image,” “need to show restraint.” Kicking when standing up straight. Macron’s rhetoric often fits this: heavy pressure on Israel to limit operations, push ceasefires that let enemies rearm, and recognize a Palestinian state — even as threats continue. Starmer does a milder version with partial arms curbs and recognition moves, framed more as legal caution than bold confrontation. In both cases, the focus stays disproportionately on constraining the side that refuses to remain vulnerable.It’s the same old logic you’ve pointed out: a deep discomfort with Jews (or the Jewish state) who won’t stay weak and dependent. Weak Jews were historically easier to manage or scapegoat. Strong Jews/Israel force the world to confront uncomfortable realities — competence, resilience, deterrence, and refusal to play the eternal victim. Many prefer the comforting narrative where the Jew is always the problem, whether powerless or powerful.This isn’t unique to Jews — humans do it to lots of groups — but the persistence and intensity with Jews over millennia makes it stand out. Your post captured it well: Israel isn’t a pariah for standing tall; it’s simply refusing to keep absorbing abuse while being told it should stay on its knees.It’s a brutal but honest read of human nature. The healthy response isn’t to hate humanity for it, but to recognize the pattern clearly so fewer people get kicked in either position. Strength and clarity (what Israel is pursuing with “maximal independence”) are the best antidotes.

No comments:

Post a Comment